@ Tatsujin - what is wrong with you? zedox10 was not critiquing your skills with photoshop but your style just as I did some time ago.
None here doubt that you have great photoshop skills and that you can make great looking signs, but you have to understand that not every bodies taste is the same. You do not have to start to act all offensive, because that way you actually do act like 5 year old.
And I have to agree with zedox10 - the crop out how ever skilfully it is made do look really random ( "..looks like[and not is like] you let a 5 year old cut papper with a scissor"), there is practically no symmetry and no logic, some may like that and some don't.
I will keep on making simple signs/avas that almost none like, everybody is free to critique that, I believe that everybody has a right to his/her own opinion and taste. And I do not use "complex" opinions given by photosho, because I do not see a need for that. As I remember from our last "discussion", you use sign/ava making to master your photoshop skills, nothing bad about that its even good, but you can not expect that everybody will like your style just because it is complicated. Look at recent BrownMaster sets - rather simple to make, but looks great.
I also think that this tread was made so that people can critique the sig/avas others have made and give advises and their opinions. You are free to critique as much as you like as long as you just do not say offensive things, like - you are and idiots and so on.
___
grhh, need to make an ava to my new sign and finish it properly.. grhh...