BakaBT > Uploaders' Forum
Koukaku no Regios (which subber)
Zalis116:
--- Quote from: BenSicard ---It does, Taka's 480p is a clear winner in that department. The Ayako xvid is exactly what it should be, a speedsub with poor image quality. It serves its purpose(it's what I watch the first time around), but has no place on an archiving site.
So, in my opinion it boils down to Taka and Ayako for their HD releases, but from what I've seen from Ayako's translations in their Xvid, I would rather have Taka for both definitions.
--- End quote ---
Under the Format Preferences, it's acceptable to have SD/XviD ("Group C") and SD/h264 + HD/h264 ("Group B"). There are a number of series that have I will confess that I have not seen this series so I don't know which group is better. That's why I was merely pointing out that Ayako's XviD may as well be uploaded since it's the only release of its type. Taka's SD/h264 and HD versions could still be added later once they're complete.
IX:
I guess I didn't look far enough into the h264 news article posted a little bit back. I remember seeing that Xvid was still being accepted in a limited fashion, but in this situation I guess I just don't see the reason as to why it should be.
Taka's h264 SD is better in every regard(though they are around 25mb larger per episode). I had thought that SD releases were allowed were to cater to people with machines that can't play 720p and up. If that is the case, then there's simply no need for a SD Xvid when a SD h264 is out.
macros74:
I just noticed Darksoul-Subs has released HD/HQ [848x480 Xvid] episodes.
Nah... Won't be taken in consideration.
Temuthril:
--- Quote from: BenSicard on June 21, 2009, 10:18:56 PM ---Taka's h264 SD is better in every regard(though they are around 25mb larger per episode). I had thought that SD releases were allowed were to cater to people with machines that can't play 720p and up. If that is the case, then there's simply no need for a SD Xvid when a SD h264 is out.
--- End quote ---
Translation differences?
IX:
--- Quote from: kureshii on May 09, 2009, 01:09:01 PM ---
Details on the Format Preferences page have finally been confirmed, and now reflects our decision to slowly move towards h264 as the only codec for new anime offers (offers for older anime shows fall under one of the exceptions mentioned). For the moment Xvid torrents will still be accepted, but we hope to phase them out eventually.
--- End quote ---
Gotta start phasing out eventually, why not start here with a show that has no decent quality Xvid releases available for it? Seems kinda silly to accept poor quality video simply because there isn't anything else. Edit: Because there isn't anything else offered in that specific codec, completely understood if there isn't anything offered for a release period.
As for the translation differences, I'm only a second semester Japanese student so I can't say that I'm in any way an authority. Someone else would have to add a weighted comment about that.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version