BakaBT > Torrent Requests Archive

Koutetsushin Jeeg [SHS | XviD]

(1/2) > >>

Zalis116:
http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=5022

We have an SD version by BB here, but it's a mess of different codecs and file formats. BB was the only complete fansub for awhile, so I appreciate their efforts. Still, it'd be better if someone could replace it with Shinsen's XviD release, to go along with SHS' HD release.

Xiong Chiamiov:
Only the first 2 eps are h.264 anyways, so I don't think it's worth keeping BB's on that basis.  It would be nice if we knew something about quality (video, TL, editing), though.

If they're otherwise equal, I'm for upping Shinsen's.

ailailou:
Shinsen-Subs (SHS) file info:

* Video: Xvid 704x396 16:9 23.98fps (799 kBit/s)
* Audio: Japanese MPEG Audio Layer 3 48000Hz stereo (192 kBit/s)
* Subtitle: English hard subs
Build Base Fansubs (BB) file info:


*
* Video:MPEG4 Video (H264) 704x384 (16:9) 23.98fps -ep1
* Audio: Japanese AAC 96000Hz stereo -ep1
* Subtitle: English soft sub -ep1

* Video: Xvid 704x396 23.98fps (418 kBit/s) -ep4
* Audio: Japanese MPEG Audio Layer 3 48000Hz stereo (192 kBit/s) -ep4
* Subtitle: English hard subs -ep4

* Video: DivX 5 704x396 23.98fps (498 kBit/s) -ep7
* Audio: Japanese MPEG Audio Layer 3 48000Hz stereo (192 kBit/s) -ep7
* Subtitle: Unknown -ep7

--- Quote from: BB's torrent ---Episodes 1-2: MKV, h.264 video, AAC audio,
Episodes 3, 5, and 6: AVI with accompanying ASS, DivX 5 video, MP3 audio
Episodes 4, 10, 11, 12, and 13: AVI, XviD video, MP3 audio
Episodes 7, 8, and 9: AVI, DivX 5 video, MP3 audio
--- End quote ---

I downloaded BB's episodes 1, 4 and 7. I tried all the possible ways to get the video and audio bitrates for episode 1 but I simply didn't manage to do it. Also, episode 7 didn't displayed any subs no mather the player I used and I'm pretty sure episodes 8 and 9 wouldn't had either. All in one, the current BB torrent is a total mess from the file structure point of view, but, in my opinion, it is slightly superior compared to SHS's image quality, as in it is more sharper and crispier while SHS's is blurier. (*see the following screenshots comparison)

SHS ep.1 | BB ep.1                                 SHS ep.4 | BB ep.4                                          SHS ep.7 | BB ep.7
SHS ep.1 | BB ep.1                                 SHS ep.4 | BB ep.4                                          SHS ep.7 | BB ep.7
SHS ep.1 | BB ep.1                                 SHS ep.4 | BB ep.4                                          SHS ep.7 | BB ep.7
SHS ep.1 | BB ep.1                                 SHS ep.4 | BB ep.4                                          SHS ep.7 | BB ep.7
SHS ep.1 | BB ep.1                                 SHS ep.4 | BB ep.4                                          SHS ep.7 | BB ep.7

ailailou:
Also, I'm for upping SHS's release too. At least for the sake of consistency, despite the lower video quality.

Xiong Chiamiov:
Mm, I do like BB's video quality better.  The inconsistency of that torrent horrifies me, though, and if you're downloading the XviD, you're not going to get amazing video quality, anyways.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page