Discussion Forums > Anime Discussions
What makes an Anime good?
Panzerseed:
I'm making this topic to see other peoples view on what they mean makes an anime the best!
For me i think i would rank an anime by the following
01. Plot (boring plot, boring anime)
02. Genre (i get more sceptical if its a genre i dislike)
03. Keeping the main story through the entire serie (fillers are most oftenly crap, thats how i got sick of naruto, bleatch etc etc...)
04. Outstanding ending (this makes me remember the anime for the rest of my life)
05. being able to compare the main character with urself (this makes me more interested to continue watching)
06. Graphics (atleast the animes graphics should be fair or okay....)
07. Eyecandy (i have needs :P)
08. A comedy with not to much cliches (you get sick of cliches if they show it on every episode)
09. the guy shouldn't be perfect, neither the girl.
10. 24-48 Episodes (12-13 too little, over 50 is too much...)
(You dont have too write about what would make all in general anime the best, but you can also describe what would make ur genre the best, my description of what would make anime the best is based on romance/comedy anime)...
enjoy! :) will be fun to see other peoples point of view
mrdkreka:
Looking at the way you are ranking an anime you must really love Neon Genesis Evangelion.
OT:
My way of ranking is a lot like yours accept for some few changes.
I will put genre on last place
Change outstanding ending to outstanding overall show.
Havoc10K:
--- Quote from: Panzerseed on March 14, 2010, 09:17:13 PM ---I'm making this topic to see other peoples view on what they mean makes an anime the best!
For me i think i would rank an anime by the following
01. Plot (boring plot, boring anime)
02. Genre (i get more sceptical if its a genre i dislike)
03. Keeping the main story through the entire serie (fillers are most oftenly crap, thats how i got sick of naruto, bleatch etc etc...)
04. Outstanding ending (this makes me remember the anime for the rest of my life)
05. being able to compare the main character with urself (this makes me more interested to continue watching)
06. Graphics (atleast the animes graphics should be fair or okay....)
07. Eyecandy (i have needs :P)
08. A comedy with not to much cliches (you get sick of cliches if they show it on every episode)
09. the guy shouldn't be perfect, neither the girl.
10. 24-48 Episodes (12-13 too little, over 50 is too much...)
(You dont have too write about what would make all in general anime the best, but you can also describe what would make ur genre the best, my description of what would make anime the best is based on romance/comedy anime)...
enjoy! :) will be fun to see other peoples point of view
--- End quote ---
all except nr 6 and 10 falls to drama section, 10 is irrelevant depending on story wich falls in the drama section, 6 falls in Artwork, youre forgetting background music, wich is fairly important.
basicaly a good anime falls in 3 sections
1- Sound
2- Artwork
3- Drama
if all 3 are above level 7 it's a relatively good anime.
Panzerseed:
thats a good point havoc =) didnt think of music.
although i dont think length is irrelevant, remember we all have different point of views =P i dont feel like i get 'to know' the characters on a 12 episode anime, but still ofcourse anime with 12 episodes arent bad at all, i just like it better if they last longer :)
manganime02:
FANSERVICE!!! And Lots of it! ;D
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
Go to full version