When silly users on the tracker who haven't read the rules properly come to experienced uploaders' torrents and bitch about the torrent being incomplete.
100% agree.
Really? That's one of the things on the tracker that amuse me. I kind of like it.
First off, sometimes they do notice something that might help improve the description (even if something isn't wrong with it, per se, something might be kind of confusing in the layout or information).
Secondly, it's a new person contributing to the tracker!!! Even if they're wrong it's great that they're trying to get involved. Maybe after somebody points out that they're wrong they'll try harder to be right next time and give an informative tip. Hell, just a week or two ago I gave some bad advice on a torrent description (Kam pointed out my error and suggested a better way

).
I know when I first started commenting on descriptions I was guilty of giving wrong criticisms. Nobody reads the wiki right when they join the site, they read it after they've been here for a few months or a year and have a growing interest/stake in the community/site.