.
I checked off the "isn't over-done" option. I actually fall closer to "No make up," but I'm more pragmatic than that. Minimal is always the best, none if it's an option. Very few of my girlfriends wore much, if any. I'm a very health-conscious type, so the sorts of women I'm attracted to are natural and focused more on the health care of what they have. I am a huge fan of natural oils and essences. Sage, cedar, patchouli, clove, rosemary, freesia, honeysuckle, cinnamon, lavender ... and many more along those lines so long as they are very natural essences, not artificial.
The ones focused on daily, heavy use aren't very attractive to me, so I've only dated about two of those type, and the relationships ended quickly. Not because of the make-up (only) but because that mind-set is an extension of personality that I don't get along with. A woman (or any person) who lives in harmony with the earth rather than as an artificial construction in conflict with it is always the more attractive.