OK, I been playing this for the past week, as I was having a lot of time (banned from forum and on holidays, spending a lot of time at home and wandering around a lot with my gf) I have to do a very short review of this game:
For Starters:
Every player for the PC, probably ordered the game, and can AND SHOULD play the first game provided with the second one, graphics artwork updated, not entirely up to the latest trends but it is updated enough, had the pleasure to play it for a while and I'm honestly amazed, the remake is great, the AMR (Alice Madness Returns) game however is a lot different, and I should scold McGee, why ? i'll tell you guys why in a bit.
The Good:
Pretty much Everything in this game is awesome.
Story 10/10
Audio 10/10
Music 10/10
Gameplay 10/10 (pretty intuitive and all buttons are near your fingers so you don't need to wander all around the keyboard)
Artwork and visual Experience 11/10 !
Yes, the game exceeded my expectations, wonderful dynamic graphics, lush scenery in one moment to later seeing a tarnished slum of London.
Mechanics in this game are awesome.
Minigames !
one of the minigames has a completely different artwork (Oriental World)
I haven't gotten past chapter 3 yet but all this game needs to be even more amazing is having Space Invaders - type of minigame.
Something console players will not like is - A lot of puzzles, and not too many fights to do.
But this is a good thing, compared to American McGee's Alice where enemies were more frequent, this game mainly develops around 2 types of enemies, the locals as I should call them are environmental native attackers, the second type is RUIN, at the start of the game we will see 2D intro, where Alice says that her mind is in RUIN, presumably those enemies are representing her struggle.
The Gameplay is very incredible, the action-adventure isn't exactly this game, you have a lot of adventure in this game, but you have to solve a lot of puzzles to obtain many secrets, many of those secrets include unlockable artwork and Alice's memories, you should focus on finding as many as you can in the first playthrough, to understand Alice better.
And now the Bad:
-No Multiplayer....
-745 memory checks
yup that is all that is bad about this game.
not enough ?
Apparently you have no idea what those memory checks are. American McGee claims that game developers are too focused on protecting their software instead of making an actually good game, he claims that no matter what protection you use, crackers will still find a way around it, so his team didn't even bother, EA however wanted to secure the game anyways, so in the midst of the game revision, they added those memory checks, oh so many memory checks, how does this work ? every several moments of the game progress, and every cutscene the game will perform a memory check to make sure the game is legit, it's a simple protection and yet so very annoying, the High end computers will not even notice this, but I have a rather mid-low end system, and I feel every check in the game, and it's terrible consequences that may follow occasionally (Game lockup, battle scene being unable to complete even when you defeat all enemies the battle still goes on due to memory check interruption, at this moment you have to restart from last checkpoint).
So the biggest asshole in the game industry (EA) takes the blame of the flames of rage on their own forum for those checks, High End systems will not be affected by those checks as they are usually performed by 3rd or 4th CPU core without interrupting the game flow.
Now the biggest Complaint is as follows:
Why oh why did we have to wait so long for this game ?

At least it's a game of 2011 for me.
Leaving DNF far behind with the disappointment it carries.
I sure hope you guys will, are and have enjoyed this game as much as I do.