Author Topic: What single malt would you introduce to a person who never drank scotch?  (Read 1551 times)

Offline rathoriel

  • Member
  • Posts: 809
  • Go Blue!
I have a good friend who has never drank scotch before and wants to try it. I am going back home soon to visit and I want to get a good bottle for someone who has never tried it. I am a big single malt fan but havent had any in years, what whould you start them with?

[16:59:46] <+xgraphy> youure a fuck troll

Offline TMRNetShark

  • Member
  • Posts: 4134
  • I thumps up my own youtube comments.
Jack Daniel's No. 7.

Or if you are cheap, Jim Bean.

Offline Burkingam

  • Member
  • Posts: 8676
  • Love, Science & Dubstep
Why would I want to poison a friend? Don't drink scotch. It tastes awful.  Real men drink Rosé.
Don't just assume that you are right. Verify with the best tools available and if you are wrong, change your mind and you will become right.

Offline rathoriel

  • Member
  • Posts: 809
  • Go Blue!
those are not scotch.

[16:59:46] <+xgraphy> youure a fuck troll

Offline Burkingam

  • Member
  • Posts: 8676
  • Love, Science & Dubstep
Don't just assume that you are right. Verify with the best tools available and if you are wrong, change your mind and you will become right.

Offline pingryanime

  • Adult Arbiter
  • Member
  • Posts: 5186
  • Japanese Dude Obsessed With Touhou and Misaka
    • Yukkuricraft
I just grab whatever's in my dad's cabinet.

*totally not underage*

Offline TMRNetShark

  • Member
  • Posts: 4134
  • I thumps up my own youtube comments.
Just because it's not made in Scotland doesn't mean it's not good. Getting a Scotch just because it's a Scotch is stupid when there are other whiskeys and bourbons that are just as good that are made in the USA. Anyone who thinks "Scotch" is the best clearly has a narrow minded view on what liquors are out there or only go for the name or where it's made.

EDIT: if you really MUST have a scotch whiskey... Laphroaig Quarter Cask is the best OF SCOTLAND. The best that you are gonna get in America though is Maker's Mark... but it's wildly expensive.
« Last Edit: June 16, 2011, 02:25:09 AM by TMRNetShark »

Offline Burkingam

  • Member
  • Posts: 8676
  • Love, Science & Dubstep
I used to love vodka, but then I got sick on it and now I can't drink anything strong anymore. Gives me nausea
« Last Edit: June 16, 2011, 02:30:15 AM by Burkingam »
Don't just assume that you are right. Verify with the best tools available and if you are wrong, change your mind and you will become right.

Offline fohfoh

  • Member
  • Posts: 12031
  • Mod AznV~ We don't call it "Live Action"
A Glenfiddish water mix?

Is that even a single malt?

Is this person the type that consumes hard liquor? Or mainly the lower end like beers, wines, cocktails etc.

If this person isn't able to handle hard liquor as easily, I suggest a water mix with ice.
If this person is able to handle the taste of hard liquor, room temp is the way to go.

EDIT: Looked it up, Glenfiddish is the only brand I even remotely have an impression on, at least for the single malts.
This is your home now. So take advantage of everything here, except me.

Offline kitamesume

  • Member
  • Posts: 7223
  • Death is pleasure, Living is torment.
lol, theres a whole crate of assorted wine and liquor at the stock room, so whatever is opened then i drink.

i like the beef jerkey in there :D and no, its just a giant fridge, the usual small fridge cant hold big bottles of juice so dad made a custom fridge out of the spare room.

Haruhi Dance | EMO | OLD SETs | ^ I know how u feel | Click sig to Enlarge

Offline fohfoh

  • Member
  • Posts: 12031
  • Mod AznV~ We don't call it "Live Action"
This might be heresy to some, but my first experience of "scotch" was mixed with cola. I did drink scotch and/or whiskey blends afterwards, and I loved having them room temp straight, but after overdoing it on an empty stomach, I haven't been able to touch scotch straight in quite a while. (Overdid dewars)
This is your home now. So take advantage of everything here, except me.

Offline harpy

  • Member
  • Posts: 8054
  • absent
Why would I want to poison a friend? Don't drink scotch. It tastes awful.  Real men drink Rosé.

+1  but one should try gin not Rosé. My favourite so far has been Beefeater

...Men are so necessarily mad that it would be another twist of madness not to be mad...

Offline AceHigh

  • Member
  • Posts: 12840
I am a vodka lover myself, but to get a good vodka you need to get it from Eastern block or the "motherland" of vodka itself.

Also, I thought that Scotch is only from Scotland. Anything else is called whiskey.
For one thing, Tiff is not on any level what I would call a typical American.  She's not what I would consider a typical person.  I don't know any other genius geneticist anime-fan martial artist marksman model-level beauties, do you?

Offline rostheferret

  • Member
  • Posts: 1584
Just because it's not made in Scotland doesn't mean it's not good. Getting a Scotch just because it's a Scotch is stupid when there are other whiskeys and bourbons that are just as good that are made in the USA. Anyone who thinks "Scotch" is the best clearly has a narrow minded view on what liquors are out there or only go for the name or where it's made.

Also, I thought that Scotch is only from Scotland. Anything else is called whiskey.

Scotch comes from Scotland, Irish from Ireland, and supposed "Tennessee" whiskey is made in an almost entirely different way, making it closer to a bourbon than a whisky really. I'm not saying one is inherently better than another, just that if it ain't from Scotland, it ain't Scotch, and I *do* think scotch is the best because I prefer it to other whisk(e)ys. You can't compare the three major kinds because they all taste completely different. Irish is the best to mix with coffee, JD tastes awful neat but mixes well with coke, and having more than three ice cubes with a decent scotch is a crime that should be punished severely. Shitty scotch, meh.

If you want to get someone to try a decent scotch, Glenmorangie 10 year (single malt) isn't too expensive, neither is Johnnie Walker Black Label (blended; the others aren't half as good, excluding gold label). Both are fairly smooth and easy to drink and avoids the supermarket trash which invariably is the bottom of the barrel, its far better to spend a touch more and get something better. Mix it with a cube of ice or two and make sure they smell it before they sip it, otherwise you get that initial surge of the strong flavour (think about how the first tequila shot makes you wince a little but after that, they go down no problem). Talisker 18 year is my favourite that I've tried - but good luck finding a bottle for under $200 over there - and if you want to shop locally, try Canadian Club Whisky; it ain't a scotch but its still surprisingly good and probably the closest thing I've heard of readily available over there.
« Last Edit: June 16, 2011, 11:05:41 AM by rostheferret »

Offline Tiffanys

  • Member
  • Posts: 7738
  • real female girl ojō-sama
Macallan or Dalmore.

Even a nice 10 year Macallan should be good.

Though, I'm more of a d'Yquem person myself.
« Last Edit: June 16, 2011, 04:36:07 PM by Tiffanys »

Offline mgz

  • Box Fansubs
  • Member
  • Posts: 10561
i would say 12 year glen livet is tasty and not overly expensive.

I cant comment on macallan because ive wanted to try the stuff and havent gotten around to it yet.

Just because it's not made in Scotland doesn't mean it's not good. Getting a Scotch just because it's a Scotch is stupid when there are other whiskeys and bourbons that are just as good that are made in the USA. Anyone who thinks "Scotch" is the best clearly has a narrow minded view on what liquors are out there or only go for the name or where it's made.

Also, I thought that Scotch is only from Scotland. Anything else is called whiskey.

Scotch comes from Scotland, Irish from Ireland, and supposed "Tennessee" whiskey is made in an almost entirely different way, making it closer to a bourbon than a whisky really. I'm not saying one is inherently better than another, just that if it ain't from Scotland, it ain't Scotch, and I *do* think scotch is the best because I prefer it to other whisk(e)ys. You can't compare the three major kinds because they all taste completely different. Irish is the best to mix with coffee, JD tastes awful neat but mixes well with coke, and having more than three ice cubes with a decent scotch is a crime that should be punished severely. Shitty scotch, meh.

If you want to get someone to try a decent scotch, Glenmorangie 10 year (single malt) isn't too expensive, neither is Johnnie Walker Black Label (blended; the others aren't half as good, excluding gold label). Both are fairly smooth and easy to drink and avoids the supermarket trash which invariably is the bottom of the barrel, its far better to spend a touch more and get something better. Mix it with a cube of ice or two and make sure they smell it before they sip it, otherwise you get that initial surge of the strong flavour (think about how the first tequila shot makes you wince a little but after that, they go down no problem). Talisker 18 year is my favourite that I've tried - but good luck finding a bottle for under $200 over there - and if you want to shop locally, try Canadian Club Whisky; it ain't a scotch but its still surprisingly good and probably the closest thing I've heard of readily available over there.
its ok ill go ahead and say it
TENNESSEE WHISKEY SUCKS DICK compared to scotch and irish whiskey.
« Last Edit: June 17, 2011, 12:17:07 AM by mgz »

Offline fohfoh

  • Member
  • Posts: 12031
  • Mod AznV~ We don't call it "Live Action"
Alberta Premium is supposed to be just as good if not better than Canadian Club. Alberta premium is supposed to be a world class whiskey and is owned by a prior owner of Jim Beam if I recall correctly.
This is your home now. So take advantage of everything here, except me.

Offline Nyx666

  • Member
  • Posts: 2
Get your hand on some Auchentoshan.  Nice scotch, not very smoky, will definitely sit well with a first timer.  Getting into Islay's types for a first time is gearing up for hating scotch for the rest of your life.  Glenlivet is a little more smoky but would still please a newbie.  12 years is the "minimum" if you don't want to feel like you're ingesting friction alcool.  The alcool taste in that case is too strong and will kill the more subtle tastes.

He asked for a scotch and single malt not a blend.  The taste of all of those are so different that it goes into personal tastes.  American whiskeys and bourbons are made from rye or corn and do taste nice and can be as refined as scotch. For some reason, bourbons are so rare here I can never buy any locally.   Demeaning one against the other doesn't do justice to any of them.  I personnaly like strong and smoky ones.

Offline kitamesume

  • Member
  • Posts: 7223
  • Death is pleasure, Living is torment.
i've tasted some liquor with 90% alcohol content, seriously BURNs.

Haruhi Dance | EMO | OLD SETs | ^ I know how u feel | Click sig to Enlarge

Online halfelite

  • Member
  • Posts: 1153
I like a Glenfiddich 18yr anything below 15 is just meh. but my roots always go back to Kentucky bourbon, good ol makers mark its been my drink of choice for so many years its hard to get away from it.

Also if this person is not a drinker scotch will not be there thing. and if you are making it there thing water it down. When i was growing up I was told to really like a good scotch start small two finger mixed with two finger of water, then slowly lower the water each time you drink it and soon enough you will be drinking it neat like a gentleman should.
« Last Edit: June 17, 2011, 08:55:23 PM by halfelite »