BakaBT > New Torrent Requests
Kanamemo (DVD)
namaiki:
--- Quote from: Daiz on July 06, 2011, 03:07:30 PM ---I'm not sure if the polished release did this any better though, the colors looked quite bleached there too. Either way, it's a mastering error and something that should be fixed for a proper rip, just like hard telecined video should be IVTC'd.
--- End quote ---
No sarcasm from me, but the rest is completely accurate.
Both groups encodes are based on the same "out of the proper TV range" video source. The CGi rip keeps the colour/detail that is outside of the TV range while polished's video has ignored it and wiped it out. Neither has fixed or adjusted it to keep all detail/colour within TV range.
CGi's release is technically better than polished, but it's still borked. That said, I have no clue how many users have their video/media player set up "properly" to expand TV-> PC range.
kristen:
--- Quote from: der richter on July 06, 2011, 03:06:35 PM ---ah i see, audio is a obvious plus. also the video resolution is not consistent, 848x480 and 720x480. seems like different raws.
if it's alright i'll make a quick comparison with episode 1. also will check the color/detail thing.
--- End quote ---
Please do.
@Daiz - OK. So a share raw vs. an ISO raw makes no difference because Japanese encoders are experts.
Daiz:
How on earth did you arrive on such a conclusion, Kristen-kun? In case you didn't notice, I was talking about the luma levels and the mastering issue related to them. Both you and the Share raw encoders failed when it came to this issue, albeit in different ways.
Fafner00:
I was trying to replace polished with coalgirls... (yes I don't like share raws too) but found nothing what better in coalgirls' release...
1) video haven't any additional details (I'm checked random episodes and random scenes (dark scenes, motion scenes), you can trust me or not, I can miss something and so on... see below ;D). Also I was thinking they fixed THIS SHIT (around 3m30s-4m20s - ep2), but they don't (maybe it's impossible ???)
2) Font size eps01-06 and eps07-13, polished release used raws with different resolution. In that case, typesetting is not accurate as in polished, nothing terrible, but still :-\...
3) all karaoke removed... but some people thinks karaore is needless shit... dunno ;D
der richter:
ok here a quick comparison. ep1 for 848x480 resolution (polished episode 1-6) and ep7 for 720x480 resolution (polished episode 7-13). there are some obvious differences in polished's release.
ep1:
cgi: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5
polished: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5
polished is overcropped. seems sharper because of the cropping and scaling, maybe also sharpened and/or line darkened. little ringing in polished, maybe simple pixelation (screen 4 her face). also see some color difference.
i think CGi is better here.
ep7:
cgi: 1 | 2 | 3
polished: 1 | 2 | 3
polished this time not overcropped. i guess overly sharpened, mayor ringing. maybe some line darkening. also some color difference.
CGi is better here.
ep2:
cgi1 | polished1
just as a comparison to namaiki full range and limited range screens on CGi's site. here full | limited
overall polished's release is overly filtered. k i did some more as i intended to do. oO
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version