Ok, I have to check out Toradora now to see what all the fuzz is about...
I re-watch Toradora and Clannad every 3 months, I re-watch FSN every 5 months, I re-watch Azumanga Daioh every 6 months, I re-watch Ika Musume every 3 months, I re-watch Spice and Wolf S1 and S2 every 4 months.
Now I'm adding a rule:
Re-Watch Horizon every 3 months as well

Id like to ask tiyler, is your friend fast forwarding ? cuz that's the only way I can think of for someone to dislike ToraDora, that show is like this:
1fun
2fun
3fun
4sad drama/tears
5fun
6fun
7fun
8tears
9fun
10fun
11fun
12tears
something like this, so the only way to dislike it is either you dislike Kugumiya Rie or you just plain skip scenes and have

in your head every other sentence because of "wut did I miss?".