Author Topic: Film Reviews and Analysis  (Read 1140 times)

Offline Kyrdua

  • Member
  • Posts: 7306
  • I have no idea what i'm doing.
    • Lunatic Red (A member there XD)
Re: Film Reviews and Analysis
« Reply #20 on: January 24, 2012, 05:30:09 PM »
Read the Taxi Driver review... couldn't really make me curious about the film. not my type of review style.

granted, the type of "review" that makes me curious are ones that highlight the tropes used in the film and not the content of the film itself. in other words. I watch a film for how it's done. not what it's about.

In anime, i look for the stuff i point out when I review (hentai board link).

In movies, I look for the following.

  • Short plot summary (Adressed the way Soryon did his, yours have too much embellishments, IMO)

  • Description of plot progression or how the story is told (e.g. starts with the middle then "what happened before", e.g. The Emperor's New Groove)

  • Selling point (sexiness, gore, enganging storytelling, special effects, etc)

  • Character Writing (how interesting the cast are)

  • Musical Score/Sound Quality (Whether they fit or not and what genre they're in)

  • Special Effects or Filming Style (Like documentary style in Surf's Up or Dug up footage of Apollo 18)

  • What will make you keep watching the movie (I remember almost dropping Sucker Punch because of the absurdity of plot progression and gratuitous slo mo)

Which makes me want to see how you'll review Shoot Em Up.

Now that i think of it. maybe I should review Sucker Punch here for an example of how I want my movie reviews. Don't really get what a "useful" review is for others so i could use some crits on my style.
« Last Edit: January 24, 2012, 05:37:50 PM by Kyrdua »
 avatar/signature: Touhou | My Links | MyAnimelist

Offline froody1911

  • Member
  • Posts: 7206
  • Confucius say man's last will is dead giveaway.
    • froody1911
Re: Film Reviews and Analysis
« Reply #21 on: January 24, 2012, 06:18:19 PM »
I couldn't get enough time to write the analysis and explanations for Brazil today :( Hopefully I can get it done tomorrow.

Thanks for suggestions, Kyrdua. Issues:

Short plot summary (Adressed the way Soryon did his, yours have too much embellishments, IMO)
This, I won't change. Most of the films I'll be reviewing have a huge focus on plot. Furthermore I can't review the characters and acting or explain the themes without adequate background. You'll just have to trust me to not put spoilers and keep it short where there's no such need.

Description of plot progression or how the story is told (e.g. starts with the middle then "what happened before", e.g. The Emperor's New Groove)
Linear unless specified otherwise, isn't that generally understood? :P

Selling point (sexiness, gore, enganging storytelling, special effects, etc)
Pointing this out isn't something I agree with. A film with just one or two "selling points" isn't something I'd give a good review in the first place. Any aspect mentioned in a review is (durr) worthy of mention (hurr), everything else is probably non-existent or negligible.

What will make you keep watching the movie (I remember almost dropping Sucker Punch because of the absurdity of plot progression and gratuitous slo mo)
I don't really understand what you mean. A film is supposed to work as a package. If you need to search for things that'll keep you watching, it's probably a bad movie.

@Shoot Em Up
Sounds like all style no substance. Should I really?
« Last Edit: January 24, 2012, 06:20:26 PM by froody1911 »

MAL | Your mother was a father and your hamster smelt of elderberries | last.fm

Offline Kyrdua

  • Member
  • Posts: 7306
  • I have no idea what i'm doing.
    • Lunatic Red (A member there XD)
Re: Film Reviews and Analysis
« Reply #22 on: January 24, 2012, 06:45:51 PM »
Hmm, how should i put this...

Quote
(click to show/hide)

The ones I underlined are what mean by embellishments. you're giving out too much details. short, concise ones are what i prefer  (like in Soryon's) Those that make you wanna know more (by watching the movie) exactly because of lacking details. that is, they tell you generic details of what a movie is about as so to spark curiosity.

Italiced ones I'd put in a separate paragraphs (e.g. like the first sentence of the last paragraph). I believe each part warrants it's own "section" no matter how short (music, acting/actors, .


Quote
Linear unless specified otherwise, isn't that generally understood?

Not really. or maybe i just have a knack for pointing out the obvious so people know what to expect.
to me, not pointing it out would be like It's like failing to say that Gungrave didn't suddenly just changed plot at episode two and that huge guy never appears again to a casual viewer who stopped watching it because it suddenly became a Goons anime.


Quote
Pointing this out isn't something I agree with. A film with just one or two "selling points" isn't something I'd give a good review in the first place. Any aspect mentioned in a review is (durr) worthy of mention (hurr), everything else is probably non-existent or negligible.
Mentioning that a movie features an element not mentioned in trailers or whatnot is pretty important to me. some movies have pretty good deceptive advertising. See Tekken Blood Vengeance. you'd expect it to be more combat centric but it actually more about a girl stalking a guy.



Quote
I don't really understand what you mean. A film is supposed to work as a package. If you need to search for things that'll keep you watching, it's probably a bad movie.

I did just use a bad movie as an example. You can say it's an "optional" thing to include.

Quote
@Shoot Em Up
Sounds like all style no substance. Should I really?

Yes, because it just sounds like that, it actually has substance. really though, I would say someone possessed you if you didn't respond with this.
 avatar/signature: Touhou | My Links | MyAnimelist

Offline froody1911

  • Member
  • Posts: 7206
  • Confucius say man's last will is dead giveaway.
    • froody1911
Re: Film Reviews and Analysis
« Reply #23 on: January 25, 2012, 01:17:21 AM »
(click to show/hide)


Brazil

(click to show/hide)

(click to show/hide)

(click to show/hide)
« Last Edit: January 25, 2012, 07:12:20 AM by froody1911 »

MAL | Your mother was a father and your hamster smelt of elderberries | last.fm

Offline Kyrdua

  • Member
  • Posts: 7306
  • I have no idea what i'm doing.
    • Lunatic Red (A member there XD)
Re: Film Reviews and Analysis
« Reply #24 on: January 25, 2012, 11:32:07 AM »
(click to show/hide)


now, Sucker Punch

(click to show/hide)
« Last Edit: January 25, 2012, 02:39:58 PM by Kyrdua »
 avatar/signature: Touhou | My Links | MyAnimelist

Offline froody1911

  • Member
  • Posts: 7206
  • Confucius say man's last will is dead giveaway.
    • froody1911
Re: Film Reviews and Analysis
« Reply #25 on: January 25, 2012, 12:01:20 PM »
^You gave that a more positive review than I expected ;D
And that review style works great with films that focus more on technical aspects, or action films. Not so much with the two I've done. Maybe I'll do District 9 next. That would let me do a more technical review.
Also, I used more spaced out paragraphs for Brazil, better now?

MAL | Your mother was a father and your hamster smelt of elderberries | last.fm

Offline Kyrdua

  • Member
  • Posts: 7306
  • I have no idea what i'm doing.
    • Lunatic Red (A member there XD)
Re: Film Reviews and Analysis
« Reply #26 on: January 25, 2012, 02:48:14 PM »
Heh, that's because I honestly enjoyed it. I don't really review things negatively unless I actually have to force myself to finish it. Though now that i think of it. I will most likely not review something i did not enjoy.

And thanks for the tip. I guess your right on that. also, the Brazil review was easy to read, good spacing.
Seems interesting too, might watch that soon.
 avatar/signature: Touhou | My Links | MyAnimelist