The reason that the same argument applies to basically all of the recent smartphones is that they've done absolutely nothing impressive.
I didn't ask you anything. You're probably confusing me with someone else in the thread.
I think it's worth considering the possibility that you're just not the intended audience for these things, rather than it being some sort of failing for the basic physical design.
These things are driven by software. More powerful hardware means more powerful software. If you just need a device to easily text, call, etc., then nothing wrong with that, but physical keyboards and the like are design tradeoffs that many would prefer not to have to make when a keyboard means less room for hardware or screen-space.
That said, there's the upcoming
Blackberry Q10 that might be more to your liking.
So is it just me and South that purchased Nexus 4? Shame on you, BBT users!
I considered it, but it was my first phone purchase and the Nexus 4 was inconsistently available until shortly after I bought my S3. The lack of an SD slot was kinda offputting too.