Discussion Forums > Anime Discussions
Is Fanservice hate nonsense?
sams88:
--- Quote from: newy on March 17, 2013, 10:53:02 AM ---What did I read in a certain manga-making manga, "You add (sexual) fanservice when the writing is poor."
--- End quote ---
Even a Monkey can draw Manga ... a classic ;D
Yes sometimes the sexual content is added when the writing is poor, but people complain even when the Fanservice is part of the Manga concept itself and when it is branded has having FS from the beginning.
Lets take the example of "Samurai Girls", in which the fanservice is part of the concept its, hint SAMURAI GIRLS short miniskirts and 70% female cast, and integrated into the Comedy. But people automatically stamp it as trash because of it, while all the plot critical plot important moments DON't feature any sexual content, except for when Muneirika kiss one of the girls to make her into a Master Samurai and it takes the whole episode.
People decide yourself, is the FS filler or distraction from the plot ?
There should be made a distinction between the two kind of fanservice.
revo:
it depends how FS looks like and how is implemented in series
GITS vs HOTD
sams88:
--- Quote from: revo on March 17, 2013, 11:40:07 AM ---it depends how FS looks like and how is implemented in series
GITS vs HOTD
--- End quote ---
Funny that you make this comparison, when someone earlier in the thread complained about how out of nowhere there is breast scene in GITS, while HOTD is consistent from day one that the FS is part of the package.
revo:
Well there is "out of nowhere" breast scene in Paprika too
What about Perfet Blue ? There you can see vagina (coverd with Pubic hair) and that does not bother me
because it was realistically presented in mature way
mrdkreka:
Do you want to know something even more annoying than fanservice hater. Hater of fanservice/dub hater. I'm with aceHigh, you can do fanservice well, where you actually try to do something with it, or you can do it poorly just because your show is crap, and you want to try hiding that fact
--- Quote ---In fact I think that fan service hate is actually an "Armchair Elitism", coming from a demographic that has probably the most porn in the planet, and TB worth of tentacle videos.
--- End quote ---
really? Sigh
--- Quote from: sams88 on March 17, 2013, 11:46:35 AM ---
--- Quote from: revo on March 17, 2013, 11:40:07 AM ---it depends how FS looks like and how is implemented in series
GITS vs HOTD
--- End quote ---
Funny that you make this comparison, when someone earlier in the thread complained about how out of nowhere there is breast scene in GITS, while HOTD is consistent from day one that the FS is part of the package.
--- End quote ---
Ever heard about context? I don't really care about FS in HOTD, since it is a terrible show even without FS.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version