I'd probably have them tied in a critical decision and then both get abducted by aliens to be honest... that sounds fun.
To be honest, I think the most damning thing to all of you is the mob mentality and it's because of the vote being public and being constantly tallied and everyone just going with the mob.
This happened as early as 6 hours in, the vote was tallied up and despite a few people having seemingly solid leads and suspicions they changed their votes to one of the popular votes in belief that their votes would be pointless otherwise. There were still
18 hours... the vote could have changed again 4 times over, but people just get tied to that mob mentality.
It is your biggest enemy here. You throw out logic and just go with the mob.
That said, I may try something different for Day 2. Something like making everyone PM their vote to me and only use the thread for discussion of who people think are suspicious and such and not allow any public tallies of suspected votes since I think that leads to the worst aspects of this game: mob mentality and blind bandwagoning.
Anyways,

Krudda: 7
jinhong91: 5
1000mAh: 1
gits: 1
Dex_Belle: 1
SeventyX7: 1
lololitas: 1
Did I explain it that badly, or did you guys just not read my entire post? 
I'm voting for him BECAUSE I know he's almost certainly innocent. Nobody else will vote for him, and therefore my vote will not have any effect on anything. At this point in the game, there isn't enough information to do anything more than make random guesses, and since it's not possible to abstain (which is what I'd like to do), I am instead wasting my vote by voting for someone who isn't going to get any other votes. That's all.
I wouldn't want to be responsible for sending an innocent to their grave, after all. I'll leave that to you guys. 
For what it's worth, your wording was perfectly fine. I understood.
Seventyx7 also sticks to his usual posting behavior, so I honestly believe he hasn't posted yet because he simply forgot he's in the game. Has anyone sent him a pm yet?
And dammit, this lynch mob turned on me. Well, since I'm screwed anyway, might as well go back to sleep for half an hour.
Oh he knows he's in the game... 